
Register Now
When/Where
- May 8, 2026, starting at 9:00am
- University of Notre Dame, Jenkins-Nanovic Hall, room 1050
Organizers
- Jacques Maritain Center, University of Notre Dame (Prof. Therese Cory, tcory@nd.edu)
- Department of Philosophy, University of Bremen (Dr. Martin Hähnel, haehnel@uni-bremen.de)
Speakers
• Prof. Therese Cory (Philosophy, University of Notre Dame)
• Dr Andrew Flynn (Philosophy, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign)
• Prof. Marko Fuchs (Philosophy, University of Bamberg)
• Dr Martin Hähnel (Philosophy, University of Bremen)
• Prof. Daniel Philpott (Political Science, Notre Dame)
• Prof. Jean Porter (Theology, Notre Dame)
• Prof. Gretchen Reydams-Schils (Liberal Studies, Notre Dame)
• Prof. John Schwenkler (Philosophy, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign)
Schedule
9:00 am, Therese Cory: Welcome and introductory remarks
9:15 am, Gretchen Reydams-Schils: Human Bonding and Oikeiosis in Roman Stoicism
10:15 am: Coffee break
10:30 am: Jean Porter: ‘Aquinas goes to Washington’: The order of love, immigration, and civic obligation
11:30 am: Break
11:45 am: Marko Fuchs: Hegel on Love
12:45 pm: Lunch break
2:00 pm, Martin Hähnel: Value and Responsibility: Max Scheler and Robert Spaemann on the Hierarchy of Love
3:00: Coffee Break
3:15 pm, John Schwenkler/Andrew Flynn: The Ordo Amoris and the 'Moral Point of View': Reflections on Taurek
4:15: Coffee break
4:30 pm, Daniel Philpott: Rendering More Than Is Due: Justice Beyond Borders
5:30 pm: Closing remarks
5:45 pm: End of the event
Abstract
This workshop gathers scholars from various traditions to examine classical and contemporary accounts of ordo amoris and its significance for today’s ethical and political challenges.
Obviously, the concept of ordo amoris—the “order of love”—has deep roots in Western thought, from Augustine and Aquinas to Scheler and Spaemann. It concerns how love should be hierarchically ordered, granting higher priority to special relationships and objects. Yet it also raises a number of important questions.
For one thing, it is unclear what the ordo amoris is. Does it describe a context-sensitive moral rule, a hierarchy of values, the unity of virtues, or a form of moral triage. Is it objective or subjective, normative or descriptive? Does its hierarchy of love imply a certain hierarchy of duties? For another thing, a fundamental concept in Western thought, seminally illustrated by the Good Samaritan parable, is the Christian imperative to extend beneficence to all, regardless of the agent's personal ties. How has the Western tradition historically reconciled these two strains of thought, one recommending partiality and the other recommending impartiality? For instance, Thomas Aquinas argues that while love should be universal, it is necessarily expressed unequally in practice. Yet he also asserts that our preferences for those to whom we have stronger ties must be set aside in cases of a stranger's more urgent need. How should we understand the relationship between these two claims? How should we think about reconciling these two strands of thought today?
Lastly, if the concept of ordo amoris carries normative weight, how should we apply it in some especially difficult contexts? For instance:
- Supererogatory acts: To what extent does the ordo amoris apply to acts that go beyond moral obligation, such as religious vocations, heroic sacrifices, or other extraordinary commitments?
- Moral duties toward distant others: How does the ordo amoris guide our responsibilities toward individuals who are psychologically or causally remote from us? For example, is it more meaningful to pray for suffering strangers than to seek direct ways to alleviate their pain?
- Normative conflicts and fairness in responsibility: In situations where moral duties clash and fair distribution of responsibility is difficult, how does the ordo amoris help us decide what is right? For instance, does a criminal’s spouse have a moral obligation to assist him in evading justice?
We will address these and other issues in the workshop.
There is a reader of primary texts available for those who would like to prepare in advance of the workshop. To obtain a copy, please email maritain@nd.edu.